The chocolate dog lifted one paw. Put it down. Lifted another, put it down. He repeated this with his other two paws. His owner/handler saw “fast paws,” and knew this canine was ready to compete.
Labeled as untrainable by his first owner and rehomed twice by age 13 months, this enthusiastic canine needed a job. That’s what Judie Niece, his third owner, believed after she agreed to take him from her mother who was about to return him to the Arizona Humane Society because he kept jumping over her cinder block six-foot backyard wall.
Judie took a chance that she’d be able to train Choco, whom she renamed Charlie. He joined her three Labrador Retrievers and her husband at their home in the Phoenix, AZ area. Judie came from a family that loved dogs. She’d shown canines in obedience, rally, and the conformation ring, so she took Charlie in as she thought she could train him. She quickly learned that he was an escape artist, a digger, a chewer, not housebroken, leery of men, and knew no commands. He scaled her wall when not on a leash but quickly bonded with Judie and her Labradors and took a liking to her husband.
ONE HUNDRED-ONE TITLES
Fast forward thirteen years. This amazing canine, labeled by the Humane Society as a chocolate Labrador Retriever, has earned 101 titles, nearly all and/ or recognized by the American Kennel Club (AKC), spread among 12 different performance sports!!
Good Grief Charlie Brown CDX, BN, RAE, JH, WC, CCA, FDC, HT, MX. MXJ, NF, CA, DCAT, SWNE, SWA, ONYX, MBMX, RATCH, CZ8G, CI, NDD, ABdFC-NDD, NAWBA’-NDD-V, CGC, CGCA, CGCU, TKP, ATT, DNX2, DJX, DSX3, AJ, HDN, IRON DOG, ASCA RN-X, JS-N, DD-JJ DD-SJ, UAD-SJ, UAD-NJII has amassed more than 600 ribbons, many blue (first place) and other colors for placements, as well as title and qualifying ribbons, says Judie, whose been the president of the Papago Labrador Retriever Club of Greater Phoenix for the last ten years. She says she’s never counted Charlie’s ribbons! Her extraordinary teammate also has won trophies, 20-24 medals, 2 plaques, and other bling.
Why is this such an accomplishment? First, he’s qualified 2,147 times to earn all his titles!!
Second, Judie estimates that Charlie qualified about 90% of the time and attributes many of his nonqualifying scores to her handling errors!
What’s Charlie’s personality like? Judie says he isn’t a cuddler but comes over for pats and attention when he so desires. At times he is aloof and other times plays with other canines. But he always wants to work! His only dislike is traveling in a vehicle!
How did Judy train this exceptional dog to compete in so many events?
Charlie started with obedience and rally because when he came to live with Judie, this “pretty wild dog” needed a good training foundation. She took him to Desert Dog obedience classes where he learned quickly. She registered him with the AKC so he could compete in its events.
At 24 months of age, Charlie earned his Canine Good Citizen certificate and Rally Novice title and then competed in obedience. After that, he trained in several different sports at the same time. Judie put different collars and/or harnesses on him in the different sports so he could distinguish what he was working on. In the early years, Judie took him every weekday night to classes for obedience, rally, and agility, and flyball on Sunday mornings.
Fortuitously, before Charlie came into her life, Judie retired from her corporate job. That gave her more time to spend with all her dogs and learn more about Charlie. She immediately learned he had a strong prey drive, and loved to work for treats.
MANY DIFFERENT SPORTS
So why did Judie train Charlie for so many different sports?
“He’s very smart. Everything we tried he loved,” she says.
“I never planned that we’d compete in so many events,” Judie laughs. “Charlie enjoys working and we are together.” He needed a job. Many, it turned out.
She kept trying different sports, thinking she would find one sport Charlie would hate. But he didn’t. The energetic tail-wagging dog loved to learn, so Judie readied him to compete in new events- and the list grew. Sometimes Charlie just watched other dogs perform and learned by watching- like carting as he observed a Bernese Mountain dog pull a cart. Soon Charlie was pulling the cart!
She took Charlie to classes and then practiced at home for obedience, rally, scent work, trick dog, and carting. The duo just went to classes for field work, agility, flyball, barn hunt, and dock diving because she didn’t have the necessary equipment/setup. Charlie learned to do what he needed to by watching other dogs for farm dog, lure coursing, and Fast CAT, as well as for the tests for Canine Good Citizen, Urban Canine Good Citizen, and Advanced Canine Good Citizen. He also earned an AKC Temperament Test (two evaluators must test and pass the dog) and Certificate of Conformation Assessment at the Labrador Nationals when he was 11 years old!
In August 2022, Charlie, at age 14, finally retired from competition at the North America Diving Dogs (NADD) regional competitions at Prescott Valley, AZ. Judie still visualizes him standing on the dock that day as he decided whether to jump. Spectators chanted “ jump Charlie.” But Charlie couldn’t hear his fans’ encouragement as he’s now deaf. He apparently didn’t feel like jumping off the dock that day but wanted to swim. So, he backed off the dock, opened a closed gate and trotted down a ramp, and leaped into the water. Spectators cheered!
Later, he gathered with his housemate, Brady (Quail Chase Here’s the Story CD, BN, RAE, FDC, NA, NAJ, FDX, CC, RATO, CZ8S, DNX7, HDJ, CGC, ATT, TKP) now 12.5 years of age with 32 titles to his name, and Doc, a yellow Labrador, age 13, all of whom were retiring from competition that day for their retirement party. All were adorned with toys, treats, and a huge rosette!
Judie believes Charlie’s favorite sports were dock diving and flyball. Charlie has jumped 421 times, she adds.
She would have been shocked years ago that dock diving would become one of Charlie’s favorite activities. He feared water at first. Judie worked with him for five years to overcome that fear by gradually introducing him to water and then adding a retrieve. His zeal for retrieving took over his fear of water as he retrieved a ball in her friend’s pool!
He was invited in 2020, 2021, and 2022 to the regional competitions of dock diving by the NADD, and six times (2016-2021) to the association’s nationals.
In 2016, he had a cyst removed from a back hock which wasn’t healed sufficiently to compete at that year’s nationals. Charlie and Judie went with two human friends and three other dogs on a van road trip to Orlando, FL for the 2017 Nationals. But in El Paso, TX, Charlie became ill with bloat. Judie rented a car and drove Charlie home where he recovered without surgery.
The following year he was again invited to the Nationals. Judie decided that her special boy needed to travel in her van with his buddy Brady. “He’s never liked riding in a car but wants to go.” Judie says he made it to Orlando after she stopped every two hours on the two thousand-plus-mile trip. “He had a great time” she recalls.
He qualified for Ultimate Air Dog regionals 2020-2022 and Nationals 2021 and 2202 in Nashville, TN.
She thinks his least favorite sport became barn hunt. He competed for more advanced barn hunt titles at the same time that he trained for scent work. In barn hunt, dogs must find a certain number of rats hidden in bales of hay depending on the class level but can’t be rewarded in the ring with food or toys. In scent work, once a dog finds a scent, the canine can be rewarded with treats.
Judie recalls that Charlie would find a certain number of rats and then quit hunting because he thought he was entitled to a treat from Judie who couldn’t oblige in the ring!
PROUD/EMBARRASSING MOMENTS
Her proudest moment with Charlie was when he not only qualified in Open Obedience at the Heart of the Desert, AZ cluster shows but also placed first three days in a row as he earned his Companion Dog Excellent title!
Has Charlie ever embarrassed his owner? Judie hesitates only for a moment and then recalls:
She entered Charlie at age three in Novice Fast at his second agility trial. In this class, dogs must run a few judge-prescribed obstacles and then the handler picks the dog’s route over 15 additional obstacles needed to qualify. Charlie sailed through the required obstacles but instead of heading down Judie’s course, he ran over and planted his two front paws on the judge’s chest! Judie yelled, Charlie here, come! But Charlie just took off on his own course, clearing obstacles left and right and again, until he finally came back to the mortified Judie. Fortunately, not only the spectators but the judge also laughed. She didn’t enter that class with him again until 2021 when she finally mustered her nerve. Charlie qualified, earning his Novice Fast title.
When Charlie was 10, Judie entered him in a hunt test- he’d practiced on dummies but when he realized dead ducks were involved, his attention soared. He loved retrieving ducks. Judie wished she discovered his enthusiasm for ducks earlier. He went on to easily earn his working certificate and Junior Hunter degree at 11 years of age.
At age 12, Charlie scared Judie when her husband announced her “heart dog” couldn’t get up from the living room floor.
Judie immediately called her veterinarian daughter, Holly Tuttle, and sent a video of him to a friend, a canine neurologist, Kim Knowles D.V.M., M.S., Diplomate ACVIM (Neurology). Both women instructed her to use a sling to help Charlie get up. He gradually took short walks in her yard. Within three days, Charlie seemed like his old self. By then he was diagnosed with spondylosis in the L-1 and L-2 regions of his back. Judie eased him gradually back into activities.
He retired first from agility and then flyball as she didn’t want him to be injured. She then turned his focus to scent work. He earned nine titles!
What does Tom (Judie’s husband) think of Charlie’s incredible achievements? Judie says Tom doesn’t really comprehend what Charlie has done and keeps himself busy by riding his motorcycles and fishing. But the couple has an agreement. Every time Tom buys a new motorcycle, Judie gets another dog. He quit buying motorcycles when Judie obtained her fifth dog!
RETIREMENT ENDEAVORS
Now that Charlie is retired what will he do? And what will Judie do?
Judie says she will take Charlie by himself to a few events so he can spend quality time alone with her and perform some of his repertoire of sports including scent work. Charlie has certainly earned the right to do whatever he chooses- within reason of course.
As for Judie? She has her hands full training her four-year-old rescue chocolate Labrador Lucy and Petey, a terrier mix that came to live with her family after his owner- Judie’s mom- passed away two years ago. And then there is Luke- a two-year-old Chocolate that she says is the most destructive Lab she’s ever had. He has so much energy that he lacks focus, so she will work with him at events where he is the only dog in the ring at a time. And Brady and Charlie will need a little extra special alone time with Judie now that they both are retired. Good luck Judie.
Judie cherishes the time that she has with her “untrainable,” one-in-a-million and one-in-a- lifetime heart dog.
Huge congratulations Judie, an exceptional trainer/handler, and Charlie, a phenominal canine!! You both deserve the best!! What an incredible team!!
RELATED POSTS:
https://www.caryunkelbach.com/the-untrainable-dog-good-grief-charlie-brown/
https://www.caryunkelbach.com/akc-sports-for-all-dogs/
https://www.caryunkelbach.com/four-generations-of-canine-lovers-competitors/
COMMENTS: Please congratulate this amazing team and/or comment in the comment section that follows the list of Charlie’s titles. Thanks!!
CHARLIE’S TITLES: All are AKC titles unless otherwise designated.
BN Beginner Novice
CD Companion Dog
CDX Companion Dog Excellent *2018 AKC Obedience Classic Invite
RALLY
RN Rally Novice
RA Rally Advanced
RE Rally Excellent
RAE Rally Advanced Excellent *AKC Rally Invitational Invite
RN ASCA (Australian Shepherd Club of America) Rally Novice
RN-X ASCA Rally Novice Title 195+ scores
LURE COURSING/Fast CAT
CA Coursing Ability
BCAT Fast CAT 150 points
DCAT Fast CAT 500 points
CARTING/DRAFTING
CS Carting Started
CI Carting Intermediate
NDD Novice Draft Dog (Bernese Mtn Dog Club)
NDD ABdFC Novice Draft Dog (American Bouvier des Flandres Club)
NDD-V NAWBA Novice Draft Dog-Veteran (North American Working Bouvier Assoc.)
AGILITY
NF Novice FAST
NA Novice Agility
NAJ Novice Agility Jumper
OA Open Agility
OAJ Open Agility Jumper
AX Agility Excellent
AXJ Agility Excellent Jumper
MX Master Excellent Agility
MXJ Master Agility Jumper
JS-N ASCA-Jumpers Standard Novice’
HERDING/FARM
HT Herding Tested
FDC Farm Dog Certificate
CANINE GOOD CITIZEN TESTING
CGC Canine Good Citizen
CGCA Canine Good Citizen Advanced
CGCU Canine Good Citizen Urban
ATT AKC Temperament Test
FLYBALL
FD Flyball Dog
FDX Flyball Dog Excellent
FDCH Flyball Dog Champion
FDCH-S Flyball Dog Champion Silver
FDCH-G Flyball Dog Champion Gold
FM Flyball Master
FMX Flyball Master Excellent
FMCH Flyball Master Champion
MBD Multibreed Dog/ (Multibreed-Racing w/ four different breeds on the line-up)
MBDX Multibreed Dog Excellent
MBDCH Multibreed Dog Champion
MBDCH-S Multibreed Dog Champion Silver
MBDCH-G Multibreed Dog Champion Gold
MBM Multibreed Master
MBMX Multibreed Master Excellent
TF U-FLI Top Flight
ONYX 20,000 Racing Points
IRON DOG 10 Consecutive Years of Racing
BARN HUNT
RATN Barn Hunt Novice
RATO Barn Hunt Open
RATS Barn Hunt Senior
RATM Barn Hunt Master
CZ8-B Crazy 8s Bronze
CZ8-S Crazy 8s Silver
CZ8-G Crazy 8s Gold
RATCH Barn Hunt Champion
FIELD/HUNT/CONFORMATION
WC Working Certificate
JH Junior Hunter
CCA Certificate of Conformation Assessment
TRICK DOG
TKN Trick Dog Novice
TKI Trick Dog Intermediate
TKA Trick Dog Advanced
TKP Trick Dog Performer
DOCK DIVING 422 JUMPS TOTAL
DD-JJ Dock Dogs Junior Jumper
DD-SJ Dock Dogs Senior Jumper * 2018 Dock Dogs World Championship Invite
’18 UAD-SJ Ultimate Air Dogs Senior Jumper *2018-2022 UAG Ultimate Air Games National Invite
’21 UAD-NJ Ultimate Air Dogs Novice Jumper
’21 UAD-NJ-II Ultimate Air Dogs Novice Jumper II
’22 UAD-NJ Novice Air Dogs Novice Jumper
DN NADD Dock Novice/ NADD-North America Diving Dogs
DNA NADD Dock Novice Advanced
DNX NADD Dock Novice Excellent
DNX II NADD Dock Novice Excellent 2
DJ NADD Dock Junior
DJA NADD Dock Junior Advanced
DJX NADD Dock Junior Excellent
DS NADD Dock Senior
DSA NADD Dock Senior Advanced
DSX NADD Dock Senior Excellent
DSX II NADD Dock Senior Excellent 2
DSX III NADD Dock Senior Excellent 3
AJ NADD Air Retrieve Junior
HDN NADD Hydro Dash Novice
*NADD Southwest Regional Invites 2020-2022
*2020 2nd Place Veteran’s Class -Junior
*NADD AKC EUKANUBA National Invites 2016-2021
SCENT WORK
SBN Buried Novice
SCN Container Novice
SEN Exterior Novice
SIN Interior Novice
SWN Scent Work Novice
SBNE Buried Novice Elite
SCNE Container Elite
SENE Exterior Elite
SINE Interior Elite
SWNE Scent Work Novice Elite
SBA Buried Advanced
SCA Container Advanced
SIA Interior Advanced
SEA Exterior Advanced
SWA Scent Work Advanced
Cary, thanks for writing a wonderful article about such a fantastic team!
And you Brenda have had the privilege of seeing this amazing team in action!
Heartwarming story of dedication and hard work (from both Charlie and his humans). All pups deserve a chance to be what they need to be. Charlie got that chance, thanks to the family who provided it!
Thanks for your comments Chris. Judie is very dedicated to her dogs. Charlie is one special boy!!
Wonderful story about Charlie ! Amazing dog and handler!
Glad you enjoyed the story, Jean. Can you imagine training a dog in so many sports?!
Thanks Cary for such an inspiring story. Loved it.
Thanks, Jean. Charlie and Judie are inspiring and amazing!
Wonderful story! What a great team Charlie and Judie have been!
They are an extraordinary team! Thanks for your comments Harriet.
Wow, what a heartwarming story about an amazing dog who had an amazing owner and trainer who recognized his strengths and allowed him to not only harness his skills but succeed in everything he did! We are lucky to have dogs in our lives. Great story, Cary!
Thanks so much for your comments Beth! Am amazing team!!
Shout out to TEAM CHARLIE AND JUDIE! Cheers to you both! What an amazing career this team has had! Thank you, Cary, for sharing this wonderful story with us!
Thanks for your comments Patty!
BEST story Cary!! I think I was quickly drawn to it because oodles of years ago (when I was doing Lab Rescue) I took in an 8 month old yellow who had been in 3 homes since being purchased at 8 weeks. Of course, the home I found for him was his “forever” home. His “new people” couldn’t figure out why anyone would give him up.
Thanks Marjorie! I don’t know how people can give up a puppy either! Was understandable with Judie’s mother as Charlie was an escape artist AND she found him a home with her daughter. Perfect!!
Cary, Thank you so much for the wonderful article chronicling Charlie’s achievements and his retirement. Thirteen years ago I never imagined the journey we’d be on together. It’s been a fun and adventurous ride!
You are most welcome Judie. You and Charlie are just an amazing team and fun to write about!!